EHCP School Placements: What is a “Conditional Duty” & Can You Request an Independent School?

Published on 29 October 2026 at 12:09

Securing the right educational placement for a child with Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) is one of the most critical—and often stressful—parts of the Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP) process.

When Section I (Placement) is being finalized, parents often ask: “Can I ask for an independent school, and does the Local Authority (LA) have to agree?”

To answer this, it helps to understand how the law separates different types of independent settings and where a Local Authority’s legal obligations begin and end.

What is a "Conditional Duty"?

Under Section 38 and Section 39 of the Children and Families Act 2014, parents have a statutory right to request a specific school or college to be named in Section I of an EHCP.

However, this full legal right only applies to:

  • Maintained schools and academies

  • Special schools

  • Approved independent special schools or colleges listed under Section 41

When you request an approved Section 41 independent school, the Local Authority is under a conditional duty to name it.

When Can the LA Refuse a Section 41 Request?

Under this duty, the Local Authority must name your requested school unless they can legally prove one of the following exceptions applies:

  1. Unsuitability: The setting is unsuitable for the child’s age, ability, aptitude, or special educational needs.

  2. Impact on Others or Resources: The placement would be incompatible with the efficient education of others or the efficient use of resources.

If the LA cannot prove one of these specific exceptions, they are legally required to list the requested Section 41 school in the final EHCP.

Can You Request a Wholly Independent (Non-Approved) School?

Yes, you can. You have every right to express a preference or make representations for a wholly independent, fee-paying, or non-Section 41 setting.

However, the legal framework changes significantly. The Local Authority is not under the same strict conditional duty to name a wholly independent school.

The General Principle: Section 9 of the Education Act 1996

Instead, requests for non-approved independent schools fall under Section 9 of the Education Act 1996. This principle states that children should be educated in accordance with their parents' wishes, provided that doing so:

  • Is compatible with the provision of efficient instruction and training, and

  • Does not cause unreasonable public expenditure.

The Onus is on Parents: What You Need to Prove

Because the conditional duty does not apply to non-approved settings, the burden of proof rests entirely on you as the parent.

If you are requesting a wholly independent setting in an EHCP or at a SEND Tribunal, you must demonstrate three main points:

  1. Maintained Options are Unsuitable: None of the schools proposed or offered by the Local Authority can actually meet your child’s documented special educational needs.

  2. The Requested Setting meets Needs: The independent school you are asking for has the expertise, environment, and resources to meet those needs effectively.

  3. Value for Money: The cost of the placement does not constitute unreasonable public expenditure. (Note: Tribunal calculations look at total costs to the public purse—including health, social care, and home-to-school transport—not just school fees alone.)

📌 Vital Step: Non-approved independent schools are under no legal obligation to admit a pupil just because an EHCP or tribunal names them. You should always secure a formal written offer or confirmation of a place from the independent school before asking for it to be written into Section I.

How I Can Support You

Navigating school placement requests, interpreting SEND law, and building a solid evidentiary case for an EHCP or tribunal can feel overwhelming.

I offer expert, personalized advocacy and advice to guide you through every step of the process. Whether you need an EHCP audit, assistance with consultations, or guidance on building a robust argument for an independent placement, I am here to ensure your child’s voice and needs remain at the center.

  • Book a Free Advice Call: If you are unsure whether your school request meets statutory criteria or need clarity on your options, let’s talk. I offer free advice calls to discuss your situation and explore practical next steps.

🌐 Visit www.practicalsendsolutions.co.uk to book your free call or discover more about my EHCP advocacy packages.