Understanding EHCPs: What is a "Conditional Duty" & Can You Request an Independent School?

Published on 15 November 2026 at 12:07

Navigating the Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP) process can feel overwhelming—especially when it comes to securing the right school placement in Section I. When mainstream settings or local maintained special schools cannot meet your child's needs, an independent school often becomes the only viable option.

However, the law treats different types of independent schools very differently. Understanding the legal framework behind school preferences is essential for making a strong, enforceable request to your Local Authority (LA).

Here is a clear breakdown of how the LA’s "conditional duty" works, and what you need to prove if you want a wholly independent school named in your child's EHCP.

What is a "Conditional Duty"?

Under Section 38(3) of the Children and Families Act 2014, parents have the right to request a specific school or college to be named in their child's draft EHCP. This right applies to maintained schools, academies, non-maintained special schools, and independent special schools approved under Section 41 of the Act.

When you request a Section 41 approved independent school, the Local Authority has a legal obligation—known as a conditional duty—to name that setting.

In simple terms, the presumption is in your favour. The LA must name your chosen Section 41 school unless they can legally prove one of two exceptions applies:

  1. Unsuitability: The school is unsuitable for your child’s age, ability, aptitude, or special educational needs (SEN).

  2. Inefficiency: Your child’s attendance at the school would be incompatible with the efficient education of others, or would result in the inefficient use of public resources (i.e., it is significantly more expensive than an alternative suitable school the LA has identified).

If the LA cannot prove either of these exceptions, they are legally bound to name the Section 41 school in Section I and fund the placement.

Can You Request a Wholly Independent (Non-Approved) School?

Yes. Many excellent specialist independent schools are not on the Section 41 approved list, or you may be looking at a wholly independent mainstream school with strong pastoral and learning support.

You have every right to express a preference for a non-Section 41, fee-paying independent school. However, because it is not on the approved list, the Local Authority is not under the same strict conditional duty to automatically name it.

Instead, your request is considered under Section 9 of the Education Act 1996. This general principle states that children should be educated in accordance with their parents' wishes, so long as doing so avoids unreasonable public expenditure.

Key Factors to Remember for Non-Approved Schools

Because the automatic presumption does not apply to wholly independent schools, the burden of proof shifts. To successfully secure a non-approved independent school in Section I—or to win an appeal at the SEND Tribunal—you must build an evidence-based case proving three key points:

  • Needs Cannot Be Met Elsewhere: You must demonstrate that none of the schools proposed by the Local Authority (whether mainstream or maintained special) can adequately meet your child’s specific SEN as detailed in Section B and Section F of the EHCP.

  • The Independent School is Suitable: You need clear evidence—such as prospectuses, curriculum details, therapy provisions, and specialist staff ratios—showing that your preferred independent school can meet every single one of those needs.

  • It Represents Value for Money: You must show that the placement will not cause "unreasonable public expenditure." Crucially, this is not just a comparison of basic tuition fees. A proper cost comparison must factor in the total public purse, including home-to-school transport, additional 1:1 support costs, and any external health or social care therapies that would have to be funded separately at an LA school.

Top Tip: Secure a Formal Offer First

Unlike maintained schools or Section 41 institutions, wholly independent schools cannot be forced by a Local Authority or a SEND Tribunal to admit a pupil. Before asking the LA to name a non-approved independent school in Section I—or lodging an appeal—always ensure you have a formal written offer of a place from the school. Without a confirmed offer, a Tribunal cannot order the placement.

How I Can Help You

Navigating school consultations, scrutinising Local Authority cost calculations, and gathering robust evidence for Section I can feel daunting to handle alone.

As an independent SEND consultant, I provide practical, legally grounded advocacy and advice to guide you through every step of the process. Whether you are responding to a draft EHCP, preparing for a mediation meeting, or building a case for the SEND Tribunal, I can help you present the strongest possible argument for your child.

Unsure whether your school request meets the statutory criteria? I offer free initial advice calls to discuss your situation, review your options, and help you plan your next steps.

Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.